The threshold of asymptopia

How thin is thin enough?

Both I and Mahadevan have been showing many pictures of crumpled sheets of fabric, paper, etc.  I said that if a sheet is thin enough, you can see certain asymptotic scaling properties.  But how thin is thin enough, and what does an asymptotically thin sheet look like.  To answer this question I asked my student Brian Didonna to make a sheet that was close to having asymptotic behavior.  This sheet has a ratio of bending to stretching energies of 5.11 to 1.  That is two percent higher than the asymptotic value of 5.  Here's what the sheet looks like, when it is formed into a tetrahedron.  You can see that the radius of curvature across the ridge is more than ten times smaller than the length of the ridges.

Brian's simulation has 79 lattice spacings between two vertices.  The elastic thickness is .00316 lattice spacings.  the gray scale is proportional to stretching energy density to the 1/6 power.