We wake up to the sound of a watch alarm that sounds like this*. The sound is a repeated double beep: the duration of each beep is about 200 millisec; the beeping continues for 20 seconds. The frequency is about 1 kilohertz. Occasionally when I am waking up in the morning, I hear it differently. Instead of two beeps, I hear four. I hear one short beep at the beginning of each beep and one short beep at the end. Instead of "beep beep, beep beep" I hear "bee-deep bee-deep, bee-deep bee-deep". Both of us have experienced this doubling at different times. This is not a vague, transient impression. We hear the doubled beeps through several cycles---enough to recognize clearly what we are hearing and to notice that this is not the usual sound. When we hear the doubled beeps, we always have one ear against the pillow. Sometimes we raise our head off the pillow during the beeping. Then the doubling ceases immediately. If we then put our head back down where it was, the doubling does not resume. We never hear the doubling when we are fully awake.
One could readily construct an electronic filter that would produce this anomaly, I believe. The sound one hears is as though the amplitude was modulated with a high-pass filter with a time constant of about 100 milliseconds. (I don't discern any exponential die-off in within one of the double beeps, but that could be because these are very short.)
Possible explanation. One possible way to account for the doubling is to suppose that it is part of an overall sensory filtering process that occurs during sleep. During sleep, one is unaware of most sound (and other stimuli) in the environment. However, some stimuli, like a loud alarm clock, penetrate our consciousness. Our physiology must be tuned to filter out some sounds while preserving others. One simple filter that would admit most sounds requiring waking would be a filter for abrupt sounds---sudden noises. Such a filter would be sensitive to only rapid changes in sound level, such as the beginning or the end of one of the beeps described above. That is, such a filter would account for the anomalous perception reported above.
Implications: Low-level perceptual filtering is commonplace in animal perception. Spatial edge detection and rapid movement detection within the retina of cats and frogs has been well documented. The novelty of the observation reported above is that the filtering is turned on or off depending on the physiological state of the animal. Further, while it is associated with sleep, it does not require unconsciousness: One can simultaneously be awake and also aware of the filtering anomaly. If this mechanism is valid, one might expect analogous filtering to occur with other senses, eg vision or touch. For example a 200 millisecond flash of light would be perceived as two flashes. Further, the doubling should not occur when the onset or decay of the stimulus is gradual rather than abrupt. Thus, if the sound reproduced above were modified so that each beep turned on and off smoothly over 20-50 millisec, one should not hear the doubling anomaly.
If you have something to say about this, please write using the link below.
T. Witten, January 2010
[I've had this exact experience!] Four beeps when waking up. Sounded exactly like a watch alarm. I looked this up an your article from 2010 is the only one I found that actually describes it perfectly. It creeped me out but Ive sense calmed down. First time this has ever happened and I just would like more information. Does not seem normal at all. An you seem to be the only one who knows what I'm talking about. Something about it just does not seem right. I feel like if it was normal or common more people would have stories about it or articles. But only you. Please respond when you get a chance I'm very curious. Everywhere else I looked for information on it did not have an accurate description for the occurennce, but yours was spot on. I'm grateful you put your experience out there. It helped me to calm down about it. So strange but cool at same time.
TW 19Nov
Since we know of three similar incidents---yours and ours---there are surely others. This is the kind of investigation that AI is good at. Eyes and memory play tricks on us. Why not ears? But if this is a known symptom, it probably has a name and a paper describing it.
TW 20Nov "It's all in the prompt"
I entered this prompt into Google/Gemini:
Primary Mechanisms
When a sharp, real sound like an alarm triggers an echo right as you wake up, two primary mechanisms explain the distortion:
• Positional Diplacusis Echoica: Sleeping on your side can temporarily compress your ear canal, trap a small amount of middle-ear fluid, or alter Eustachian tube pressure in the downward-facing ear. When the alarm rings, sound waves reach and stimulate one inner ear slightly slower than the other—creating a split-second, mechanical "double hearing" effect that disappears once you sit up and pressure equalizes.